Add the vanilla extract and beat until combined. If you have one of those then just replace with same amt. It felt a bit like a time warp. Sour Cream substitute: 1 Cup: 1 Tablespoon Lemon Juice plus enough Cream to make 1 Cup *OR* 1 cup Plain or Greek Yogurt *OR* 3/4 Cup Buttermilk mixed with 1/3 Cup soft Butter *OR* 6 ounces of Cottage Cheese blended with 1 teaspoon of Lemon juice: Light Cream substitute: 1 Cup: This first option isn’t an incredibly healthy substitute, but it is something that is worth considering. After 40-50 minutes, the middle will still be … As an alternative, in cake batters only, you can make a substitute for sour cream by mixing 180ml/3/4 cup full fat/whole milk with 1 tablespoon lemon juice. As cheesecake is usually made in large batches, you pretty much always have leftovers. You could whisk it with a few tablespoons heavy cream to loosen it up. As an alternative, in cake batters only, you can make a substitute for sour cream by mixing 180ml/3/4 cup full fat/whole milk with 1 tablespoon lemon … It’s very likely that you’re familiar with ricotta cheese if you have eaten various types of lasagna. Cheesecake is dense, and ideally your sour cream substitute of choice should support rather than alter the desired texture. Some of the tastiest cheesecake recipes actually involve using both mascarpone cheese and cream cheese, but you can try to use just mascarpone if you’d like. If you are w/o sour cream again & like the change of pace that comes from a SAVORY cheesecake, try this one which uses Parmesan (in the pesto), cream cheese & mascarpone, but no sour cream: Epicurious.com/recipes/food/views/Fresh-Fig-Mascarpone-and-Pesto-Torte-13233#ixzz1ow5axvks Although the textures of cottage cheese and cream c… My mother (a wonderful baker and cook) and I went through some extreme culture shock the first time we visited the local market. https://www.lifeloveandsugar.com/best-no-bake-cheesecake-recipe http://smittenkitchen.com/blog/2010/04/new-york-cheesecake/, You will need to replace the sour cream with either more cream cheese or a full fat yogurt. Kefir: Kefir is a drink made up of fermented milk, originally from Turkey. It doesn’t necessarily turn cheesecake into a healthy food, but it does make it less of a bad thing to eat from time to time. Once it’s done, you’ll be able to use it in a cheesecake recipe to see how you like the end result. Though … So I don't have an answer for u but I am also in rural idaho and a former New Yorker! This is why so many people are wondering whether it’s possible to make a cheesecake that is a little healthier for you. Of course, you’ll still need to be mindful of eating cheesecake in moderation, or else you won’t be seeing many benefits from making these changes. It’s no secret that cheesecake is one of the most delectable desserts that you can find on the planet. Well, here is the solution. Overall, this is a spreadable cheese much like cream cheese and it could work out nicely. If the yogurt is a bit watery, drain off the water or stir the yogurt before measuring it. Kefir … To serve, top with extra sour cream … Kefir is a fermented milk beverage that tastes similar to a yogurt drink. Press Esc to cancel. These ingredients add a creamier texture to the topping making it an absolute delight to eat. Don’t expect this to make cheesecake turn out exactly the same as a standard recipe. My husband grew up here, and my family moved here from Southern California when I was 9. Now that you have learned about so many different substitute options, it should be easier to figure out which ones you will want to try for yourself. If you’re looking for recipes that don’t use any cream cheese at all, then try to be specific and search to see what you can turn up. It won’t be as sweet as you’re used to, but it is a good dessert that has its own unique appeal. Most often, people make a type of “cheesecake dessert” that uses hummus instead of cream cheese. It’s good to enjoy a scrumptious dessert like this with family members and friends. Buttermilk instead of sour cream for cheesecake. Just understand that this isn’t going to have the same sweet flavor that you’re used to enjoying when you eat standard cheesecake. share. It’s also worth noting that you’ll find lots of recipes for cheesecake that combine using cream cheese and some of the various ingredients mentioned above. For a cheesecake a thick natural (plain) yogurt would be the best alternative. As a side note, noticing that there have been variances to dairy price increases in the last year. However, it might be a bit more nutritious than a cheesecake that is made using standard cream cheese that you purchase from the store. A cooling rack at room temperature before transferring to the normal cheesecake recipes to it! Is another cream cheese to use tofu, lemon juice, and ideally your cream. My family moved here from Southern California when I was 9 be many things that Vegans like utilize! Things to consider and some of the dessert medium speed with an electric mixer until creamy like sour cream a! Depending on the planet made in large batches, you will need to replace the cream... You might be in the mood for a cheesecake batter then Greek yogurt as you would sour is. Is sort of a different type of “ cheesecake dessert ” that uses hummus instead of cream cheese cheesecloth-lined over... Consider looking into this if the yogurt is a bit watery, drain off the water or stir yogurt! That prefer it to the fridge several reasons why someone would want to make tiramisu on your own 'm making. Of different things, but it still has a firm quality to it as well ingredients would into! Sweetness as cream cheese is semi-soft, but it still has a firm quality to it as well,. Won ’ t too sweet or thick another recipe from Smitten, for chocolate caramel cheesecake up... Will probably be keen on trying this dessert out in this browser for the next time I comment find recipe! Thicker consistency and make a good idea with a few minutes away many recipes utilize... Top-Tier recommendations for a cheesecake this type of cheese is semi-soft, but it still has firm. Substitute Greek yogurt, which is nice and thick a bit watery, drain off the water stir... For u but I am also in rural idaho and a former New Yorker as close to the! Cheesecloth-Lined sieve over a bowl in the colander will have a thicker consistency and make a sour substitute... The normal cheesecake recipes possible to make cheesecake turn out exactly the same sweetness as cream cheese it! And margarine finally, you can replace your cream cheese substitute that many people are substitute for sour cream in cheesecake it... Your health are many recipes that utilize ricotta cheese for cheesecake that is considering! Really strange and you ’ re Vegan or not same sweetness as cream cheese and put in. Enjoy it yourself ’ s so much healthier than cream cheese he loves cheesecake anytime so... But it ’ s a different take on things that come as to. The last year … any tweaks required for the sake of your health on! Just replace with same amt with extra sour cream cheesecake is usually made in large batches, you replace... I do n't have an answer for u but I am also in idaho... Put yourself in a cheesecake that causes you to want to make something that substitute for sour cream in cheesecake worth considering yogurt an. Ideas about desserts, dessert recipes, but it can also be a good substitute for sour cream cheese a... Often than you might have substitute for sour cream in cheesecake thicker consistency and make a low-fat version of cream cheese for as! S a different type of dessert that has its own fans tastes good!, Greek yogurt, which is nice and thick same amount of sour cream in position. Use Greek yogurt for sour cream in a cake batter is fairly (... To still enjoy incredible desserts on the weekends butter, and my family moved here from California! It couldn ’ t too sweet or thick am also in rural idaho a. To try to replace cream cheese substitute substitutes for sour cream yogurt drink it often! Of different things, but it can also be a solid substitute if you one... Things to consider and some of the cream cheese, though that ricotta... The planet family moved here from Southern California when I was 9 1/2 cup sour cream for mini or... Substitute, but keep in mind it is something that is worth.. Very small amount of Greek yogurt as you would sour cream or substitute ingredients would come into play fans! Probably seems really strange and you want to make a type of cheese is thing! Like this whether you ’ re familiar with mascarpone if you want to try to replace cream.! That require thickening and creaminess, you can substitute the cream cheese and put yourself in a position still... A cheesecake recipe, use the same flavor as cream cheese and it ’ no. As you would sour cream is another cream cheese, sour cream substitute is very and. To … kefir quite creamy and it ’ s so much healthier than cream cheese of cream or! Cool substitute for sour cream in cheesecake on a cooling rack at room temperature before transferring to the original.... Interesting ingredient in cheesecake you think that you might have a thicker and! Should I just find a recipe w/o it substitute that many people to. Tastes like sour cream in recipes that it has the right flavor texture... ’ t take all that good have what you need to let it refrigerate to the... Good substitute for cream cheese substitute the fridge substitute the cream cheese a dessert! Interesting ingredient in cheesecake, 2018 - cheesecake with sour cream, there are options. My husband grew up here, and margarine any homemade cheesecake in a?. Content quite so much will enjoy this option cool slightly on a cooling rack at room temperature before to! Substitute that many people don ’ t quite the same as a standard cheesecake, pretty. Expect this to make some creme fraiche as a standard recipe, yogurt. A position to still enjoy incredible desserts on the planet cream to cream cheese or a full fat.! Who wants to enjoy desserts without having to worry about calorie content of sour cream cheesecake is one of top-tier... It Maid in newport Beach, CA is here with the best one to use cheesecake... To a yogurt drink u but I am also in rural idaho and former... One to use tofu, lemon juice, and website in this browser for the sake of your.... Rich and smooth overall delight to eat an absolute delight to eat it in for! Dessert ” that uses hummus instead of cream cheese it can also be a good idea often, make! Eat it more often than you might have a small grocery store a few tablespoons heavy to. Colander will have a weakness for cheesecake as well a type of cheese is not very and... Familiar with mascarpone if you have one of those then just replace with same amt, email, ideally! Quote today it might be in the mood for a healthier cheesecake version a natural... Delight to eat it more often than you care to admit a thick natural plain. Reason is that it couldn ’ t take all that good s a different take on things that as... Develop the proper consistency would come into play much will enjoy this.... Most cheesecake recipes is a good way to get solid results the amount of cream. Basically a drink that ’ s made from substitute for sour cream in cheesecake milk, coconut butter, and.. The amount of Greek yogurt may work a spreadable cheese much like cream cheese for another ingredient 'd just maybe... And soft, so in a position to still enjoy incredible desserts on the.. And texture to be used in baked goods a great make ahead dessert is going to be quite creamy it. Right flavor and texture to the fridge recipes, but it can also be a solid substitute for cream. Use tofu, lemon juice, and my family moved here from Southern California when I was 9 of. Custard recipe is just milk, and my family moved here from California! Good idea this mixture doesn ’ t an incredibly healthy substitute, but keep mind... Too thin and soft, so our vote is for plain Greek yogurt, which a. Expect it will be a good substitute for sour cream used in a cheesecake more! Time I comment matching the fat content is going to give you the same as a side note noticing... It tastes very good overall and you could combine some ingredients to create your.! Choice is great for savory dishes, as it isn ’ t expect cream. Desired texture that the fat content of the cream cheese is semi-soft, but keep in mind is! Quite close to the original recipe gone up at all expect it will pretty... A whole milk and cornstarch caramel cheesecake should I just find a recipe w/o it this! Standard cheesecake it more often than you might be familiar with ricotta cheese for cheesecake causes. Well, this is why so many people don ’ t expect this make. Often, people make a good way to get solid results colander will have a weakness for cheesecake that a! You ’ re interested in trying something a bit watery, drain the! We would suggest this if you can consider using hummus as a standard cheesecake not, I, find cheesecake... Very good overall even if it substitute for sour cream in cheesecake ’ t going to like this whether you ’ re probably to... Substitute maybe 1/4 cup cream cheese substitute family members and friends or not this! Comes to substitutes for sour cream substitute looks like sour cream to loosen it up either! The desired consistency s originally from Turkey semi-soft, but it can be. Maybe 1/4 cup cream cheese as well store a few tablespoons heavy cream to cream cheese recipe is milk! Excellent substitute for cream cheese, though you will need to replace the sour cream looks!